« All LBI Homes for Sale

Mystic Island Homes for Sale

Little Egg Harbor Township • Mainland Near LBI

Mystic Island is a large residential community in Little Egg Harbor Township, offering an extensive network of lagoon canals, bay access, and waterfront properties at some of the most competitive prices in the region. It’s one of the most sought-after value plays in the LBI area — a community where buyers can own a lagoon-front home with a dock and access to Barnegat Bay for significantly less than comparable properties on the island itself.

Mystic Island has a large, established year-round population alongside seasonal residents, giving it a genuine community feel. The Garden State Parkway is easily accessible, and LBI is just a short drive away. For buyers who want the shore lifestyle at a realistic price point, Mystic Island consistently delivers.